When Sam got promoted to manager, she thought she was ready. After all, she’d been the go-to person in her team for years. But just three weeks into the role, her confidence wavered. She found herself stuck between being “one of the gang” and “the boss,” unsure how to give feedback without sounding harsh, and overwhelmed by the sheer number of decisions landing on her desk.
Sam’s story is common and it’s why so many first-time managers struggle. They’re promoted for their technical skills, but the leadership skills they need often emerge later……if at all.
That’s where well-designed learning and development (L&D) makes the difference. But not all manager training is created equal. To truly support new and aspiring leaders, we need to design programmes that match their real development needs — not just a generic syllabus.
Here’s how to create L&D that grows confident, capable managers from day one.
-
Start With the End in Mind – What Does a Successful Manager Look Like?
Before building a single training module, define success. What does “good” management mean here — in your organisation, with your culture, in your industry?
Ask:
- What behaviours do we want to see every day?
- What challenges trip up our managers most often?
- What do our best leaders do differently?
The answers form your competency framework — a blueprint for everything that follows.
Top Tip: Include voices from different levels from senior leaders, current managers, and even team members. They’ll spot gaps you can’t see from one perspective.
-
Match Learning to the Management Journey – Not Just the Job Title
Not all managers need the same training. A one-size-fits-all approach often results in overload for new managers and underwhelm for experienced ones.
Instead, create staged pathways:
- Aspiring managers: Focus on mindset, self-awareness, and the reality of leading people.
- First-time managers: Prioritise core skills — giving feedback, delegating, setting expectations, and handling conflict.
- Established managers: Introduce strategy, influencing, and leading change.
Top Tip: Think “Netflix playlist” for learning with modules people can pick up when they’re ready, not all at once.
-
Blend Formal Learning with Real-Life Practice
Leadership can’t be learned from slides alone. What sticks is applying new skills in real situations.
Blend:
- Workshops with live roleplays
- On-the-job stretch projects
- Peer problem-solving groups
- Reflection journals
- Shadowing experienced leaders
These approaches bridge the gap between theory and reality and help managers adapt lessons to their own teams.
Top Tip: Build “learning loops” — short follow-up sessions to share what’s been tried, what’s worked, and what needs rethinking.
-
Include Emotional Intelligence, Not Just Technical Skills
A manager who can create trust, stay calm under pressure, and have difficult conversations is far more valuable than one who simply ticks off tasks.
Your programme should include:
- Emotional intelligence and empathy
- Building psychological safety
- Coaching and listening skills
- Resilience and stress management
Top Tip: Use real, anonymised scenarios from within your organisation. When people recognise their world in the training room, lessons land harder.
-
Give Line Managers a Role in the Learning Process
If the learner’s own line manager is uninvolved, new skills often fade within weeks. Make them a partner in the process:
- Before: Help set clear goals and expectations
- During: Give permission to practise new approaches
- After: Review progress and coach through challenges
Top Tip: Provide line managers with conversation guides so they can have meaningful development check-ins.
-
Make Learning Visible and Valued
If leadership development is seen as “extra work,” it’ll always be pushed aside for urgent tasks. Make it matter.
Recognise learners who apply their skills. Share success stories in company updates. Link completion of modules to career opportunities.
Top Tip: Create a “Manager Spotlight” where one leader shares a real change they made as a result of the programme.
-
Measure What Matters – Behaviour Change, Not Just Attendance
Don’t stop at sign-in sheets or end-of-day feedback forms. Track whether the training is changing how managers work:
- Are they giving feedback more regularly?
- Do teams report greater clarity and support?
- Are performance issues handled faster and more effectively?
Top Tip: Use 30/60/90-day check-ins to capture lasting impact and refine your programme.
Final Thoughts
Sam’s early struggles as a manager weren’t because she lacked potential. She lacked the right development at the right time. The good news? That’s a fixable problem.
When we design L&D that matches the real needs of managers by blending practical skills, emotional intelligence, and ongoing support. We don’t just create leaders who manage. With our guidance, we develop leaders who inspire, enable, and deliver results.
At Aim Higher Training, we build manager development pathways that are modular, practical, and accredited. Our approach gives your leaders the confidence to lead from day one, and the skills to keep growing for years to come.
We’d Love to Help
Whether you’re an HR leader, L&D professional, or team head looking to support first-time managers in your organisation, we’re here to help.
Our Management and Coaching Programme is designed to make a real, lasting impact. Not just on individual performance, but on team culture, leadership capacity, and business growth.
- Get in touch today to explore how we can tailor a solution for your team.
- Visit: aimhighertraining.com
- Email: [email protected]